The evolution of oscillations is a very important issue in traffic flow studies. A recent car-following experiment (Experiment-I) showed that the speed standard deviation grows in a concave way along a platoon of vehicles following one another. This finding indicates that the traditional traffic instability mechanism is debatable, in which the speed standard deviation initially grows in a convex way. This paper has investigated the growth pattern of traffic oscillations in another car-following experiment (Experiment-II) and compared it with that in Experiment-I. It is shown that the speed standard deviation also exhibits concave growth characteristics in Experiment-II. The paired-sample t-test and the Mann-Kendall (MK) trend test showed that there is no significant difference between the two datasets. However, the acceleration standard deviation was remarkably larger in Experiment-II since drivers were asked to follow closely. Furthermore, a comparison experiment has been performed which indicates that the set of experiments on a circular track can be considered equivalent to that on a straight track. Our study is expected to shed light not only on traffic flow dynamics itself but also on the future design of the experiment scheme.
