Ru$_{2-x}$Fe$_x$CrSi ( 0 $<$ x $<$1) system is theoretically predicted to be one of the very few known examples of robust half-metallic ferromagnet with 100\% spin polarization. Since Cr is considered to be the main contributor to magnetism, the Fe/Ru substitution is not expected to disturb its magnetic properties any significantly, and hence all Fe-containing members of the series are predicted to follow Slater-Pauling rule with a saturation magnetic moment of 2 ${\mu_B}$/f.u. However, contrarily to the theoretical expectations, some experiments rather show a linear variation of the saturation magnetization and Curie temperature with Fe (\textit{x}) substitution. The equiatomic member FeRuCrSi of this family is also considered as a technologically important material, where the band structure calculations suggest the material to be spin gapless semiconductor. Through our in-depth structural analysis of FeRuCrSi using X-ray diffraction, extended X-ray absorption fine structure and $^{57}$Fe M\"{o}ssbauer spectrometry, we found a random disorder between Fe and Ru sites, while the magnetic moment in this system is actually contributed by Fe atoms, questioning the very basic foundation of the half-metallic character proposed by all theoretical calculations on Ru$_{2-x}$Fe$_x$CrSi series. Our M\"{o}ssbauer result also envisions a rather rare scenario where the main physical properties are intricately correlated to the chemistry of the material in the form of random atomic disorder on a localised scale.
